Encanto's Abuela could be the reason why Mirabel never got a gift like those of the rest of the family, all due to her past mistakes. Like Mirabel, Abuela lacks a tangible magical ability like super hearing or seeing the future, but rather acts as the glue that holds the rest of the family together. In that sense, one could argue that Abuelas actions led to the Madrigal familys problems. While Abuela may not blame Mirabel for the familys breakdown, it is clear that she is deeply hurt by the situation and is struggling to come to terms with what has happened. so, after mirabel's gift ended the way it did, isabela would've had a front row seat to alma's resentment for mirabel developing and when alma criticised all of mirabel's actions, isa could've very easily internalised this cause and effect. Related:Encanto Subtly Revealed Its Mirabel Power Twist At The Beginning. This theory illustrates that Mirabel never needed to prove herself to Abuela, but rather only to herself. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-medrectangle-3-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'coalitionbrewing_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_8',146,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-medrectangle-3-0'); These could be strained relationships with her own parents, financial hardships or oppression faced as an immigrant. While viewers would definitely tune in to see more of Mirabel's adventures, Encanto 2 could leverage the first movie's greatest strengths by explaining Abuela's powers in Encanto, and revealing more about her story before and after Abuela's time as a war refugee. It's changed because Mirabel stood up for herself and for her family. Every character inEncanto possessesa meaningful gift via the miracle that began when Pedroand Alma fled their home and Pedro was killed. All she does is be rude, mean, and degrading towards her! Grandmas secret with Mirabel was that Grandma was happy to have her in her life. Looking at Mirabel, she perhaps sees and relives the trauma that happened years ago when the magic began. She became consumed by her grief and shut herself off from the world. Come, I want all of the grandchildren together!" The movie is a heartwarming tale of family, love, and resilience, and all the characters, including Abuela, contribute towards this message. Her trauma has led to her becoming a rigid and traditional leader, who struggles to adapt to change and let go of the past. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. At the end of the Encanto,Mirabel and Abuela reconcile, whichis only possible once Abuela has shared her traumaand begins working on herself. Lastly, Abuela depended too much on the magical properties of her music to protect Encanto from its enemies. Aunt Pepa's mood affects the weather, and mom Julieta's cooking heals people's wounds. Mirabel had always been close to Abuela and looked up to her for guidance and wisdom, so finding out that Abuela had been keeping something so significant from them was shocking and unexpected. It's Mirabel and Abuela Alma. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); What are the 4 Behaviours that indicate a relationship will fail? Disney. As Abuela sings in 'All of You', "The miracle is not some magic that you've got / The miracle is you / Not some gift, just you, the miracle is you / All of you, all of you". abuela and mirabel argue full part 1. abuela yelling at mirabel voiceover. Cookie Notice By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. And after that, Alma realized what she had done and made amends. It is unclear if Mirabel will take over for Abuela. Warning: Contains spoilers for Encanto. Abuelo Pedro was killed because of a political conflict in his home country of Chile. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. At the beginning of the story, it is clear that Abuela is trying to punish Mirabel for sacrificing a part of her education to help support her family financially during hard times. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-box-3-0-asloaded{max-width:728px!important;max-height:90px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[728,90],'remodelormove_com-box-3','ezslot_3',175,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-box-3-0');Without male presence in the home Abuelas husband has since passed away loneliness can be a hard pill to swallow. In Encanto, Abuela made a few mistakes that ultimately put her family and the magical village of Encanto at risk. We continue to learn about the Madrigals' powers as the main character, Mirabel, sings her opening number, "The Family Madrigal." After discovering the truth about Abuelas past, Mirabel realized that Abuela was a survivor of a traumatic event who had to make tough decisions. Encanto has been a strong success for Disney in many ways, and one of the film's greatest strengths is how it underscores the value of family by pointing out that every member of the Madrigal family has value, with or without a magic gift. It is important to recognize signs of gaslighting and seek help if you or someone you know is experiencing it. On the other hand, its also possible that Abuela simply didnt have a gift to give to Mirabel. The vision shows flashes of the future, and . For more information, please see our Abuelas judgmental and strict demeanor can be attributed to her lack of childhood and the burden she carried as a young girl. Speaking of home, they both lose theirs. if you have another idea, feel free to leave them in the comments! 5. Instead, it's the family Madrigal coming together, loving one another, and being happy that is the true magic that sustains their miracle. Why does Mirabel hug her sister? - EmojiCut Mirabel was the only member from the family who had the guts to confront her about her awful attitude. By the end of the movie, we learn that the miraculous candle is not so, well, miraculous. What is her problem? No, Abuela is not the villain in Encanto. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-leader-2-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'coalitionbrewing_com-leader-2','ezslot_14',154,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-leader-2-0');In examining the situation, it is clear that Abuela is struggling with a deep sense of grief and loss after the familys painful breakup. why isabela hated mirabel my interpretation & discussion there's a plethora of evidence that alma is projecting onto isa due to their physical similarities, and the similarities between mariano and pedro, and that she is pushing isabela to have the life that she, herself, couldn't lead. What major life activity does ADHD limit. They could have talked with her in a serious tone, and tell her to stop putting pressure over them. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Home Encanto, Casa Madrigal Personal information Affiliation Madrigal Family Occupation Matriach Relatives Pedro Madrigal (husband) Julieta Madrigal (daughter) Pepa Madrigal (daughter) Bruno Madrigal (son) Flix Madrigal (son-in-law) Agustn Madrigal (son-in-law) Isabela Madrigal (granddaughter) Dolores Madrigal (granddaughter) harsh on other members of the Madrigal family. This had a ripple effect on her relationship with her family, particularly with her daughter, Julieta, who blamed her mother for not being there for her after Pedros death. They both want the other's life. Even worse, as a young girl during this time, she saw many of her family and friends killed. Therefore, Abuela was devoted to helping mold Isabela into the best version of herself that she could be and was determined to keep the admiration and love between them strong. A hint at Abuela's "power" reveals itself during Antonio's ceremony (where we learn his power is talking to animals). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. However, the movie manages to strike a balance by showing the audience that Abuela understands the weight of her mistakes and takes steps to make things right. The newest offering on Disney 's list of animated movies, Encanto has won Disney fans over with its colorful setting of magical realism that honors its Colombian background. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'coalitionbrewing_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_12',152,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0');This not only invalidates Mirabels cherished memories but also makes her doubt her own recollection of events. As we learn later in the film, Abuelas magic is tied to the magic of the house, and if the house is damaged or threatened in any way, Abuelas powers weaken. She is the matriarch and the keeper of the familys magic, and she is also the one who decides which family members receive magical gifts. and our While Abuela never explicitly blames Mirabel for the issues that arise within the family, she certainly expresses a sense of disappointment and frustration with her granddaughter in the aftermath of the events. So, no, an apology scene is not "unrealistic". Archived post. Of course the abuela wasn't going to stop her pressure since no one had a serious talk with her. Archived post. 23 hours ago, by Njera Perkins by Mekishana Pierre An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. Sheis also harsh on other members of the Madrigal family, but Mirabel becomes distinctively left out. Encanto: Mirabel's Hidden Gift Explains Why Abuela Doesn't Really Like Her She is seen as the nurturing and supportive backbone of the family, always there to offer guidance, impart wisdom and provide comfort to anyone who needed it. In 1973, Chile experienced a military coup led by General Augusto Pinochet, who overthrew the democratically elected president Salvador Allende. Thus, Abuela's power and responsibility are to keep her family together. With a deep-seated belief in the value of hard work and family values, Abuela has placed a high emphasis on the importance of education and her expectations of achievement within the Madrigal family. Powers and Abilities Abuela Alma doesn't possess any particular gift, due to being the one who found the miracle that blessed the Madrigal family in the first place. The biggest mystery in Disney's Encanto is why Mirabel didn't get a gift, and a theory suggests it's all due to Abuela's previous mistakes. those efforts were perceived as threats to the sanctity of their miracle and day-to-day life and was unwelcome, but when mirabel continued to push anyway, faced the worst case scenario as their house was falling apart but was still able to pick herself back up and fix the family, the necessity of mirabel's actions becomes clear. i'm very curious to hear your thoughts. But Abuela's power may actually be the most important of all the Madrigals' abilities. I don't understand why Isabela gets surprised when Mirabel - Reddit By insisting on rigid roles for her grandchildren, she created pressure on Isabella to live up to her miracle-giving expectations, which only increased her anxiety and self-doubt. Related: Encanto Ending: Does Mirabel Have A Power Now? This put a lot of pressure on her, and she had to grow up very quickly. Her counterpart seemed to have such a good relationship with Abuela. She is grappling with the fact that the family has been torn apart and is struggling to find a way to come to terms with the situation. When Mirabel came into her life as an adopted daughter, Grandma was overjoyed and decided that she wanted to make Mirabels life as special as possible. That's why, when the family stop ostracizing Mirabel and Bruno, start following their hearts, and rebuild their house in solidarity, they all regain their powers in the process. we never really see her reaction to mirabel standing up to alma, beyond glances and looks between her and luisa, but it seems like this is the moment where isabela has realised that alma, and herself by proxy, was wrong about mirabel. Why is Abuela so disappointed in Mirabel when she also doesn - Reddit Abuelas trauma was rooted in her experiences during the Spanish Civil War and her time in exile. Why was abuela so mean to Mirabel? Therefore, while she did contribute to the Madrigals problems, it would be unfair to solely blame her for the familys strife. If Mirabel had gotten a gift, it could have only served as a distraction for Abuela, and she might not have processed her past. Ultimately, whether or not Mirabel will take over for Abuela depends on the nature of Abuelas role in the story as well as the expectations of the other characters in the story. The people who watches and don't act are responsible too. The abuser may use tactics such as denial, blame, lies, and manipulation to make the victim question their own reality. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. However, if Abuela shows genuine remorse and takes steps to make amends, such as apologizing and changing her behavior, it can make it easier for Mirabel to forgive her. Abuela, played by actor of the voice of Rita Moreno, was a loving and dedicated grandmother who only wanted what was best for her family. While all signs point to the Madrigals' powers depending on the magic candle (including Bruno's visions), it turns out this is one of the central misunderstandings that drives Encanto and holds the answer to what Abuela's power really is. and our Isabela Madrigal is a major character in Disney's 2021 animated feature film Encanto. with mirabel and her perceived failure, alma likely went into a paranoid frenzy - maybe this was around the time that her insistence that the family work twice as hard, in order to keep the magic strong came into the picture? It may take time and effort on both sides to rebuild trust and repair the relationship, but it is possible for forgiveness to occur. In the movie Encanto, Abuela, the matriarch of the Madrigal family, tries to protect her familys miracle-giving magic with a heavy hand. On the other hand, if there have been underlying issues or tension between them, it may be more difficult for Mirabel to forgive Abuela. Let's Investigate, Dua Lipa's Sister Rina Is Making Her Acting Debut, Ashley Park's Star Turn Anchors the Hilarious and Absurd "Joy Ride", We Found the Best Merch For Your "Barbie" and "Oppenheimer" Double Feature, What to Know About "Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny"'s Basil Shaw, Why Indiana Jones's Son, Mutt Williams, Isn't in "The Dial of Destiny", Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Instead, she is in charge of all magic of the family. Since then, the candle has burned and protected Casita, the family, and the whole town, while also granting special gifts to each Madrigal descendant, except for Mirabel (Stephanie Beatriz). The Way To Tomorrow - Chapter 12 - Archive of Our Own Its possible that Abuela played a role in the situation, but its also likely that other factors were at play. She had to juggle school, work, and taking care of her siblings, which caused her to miss out on crucial opportunities in life. Grandma encouraged Mirabel to pursue her dreams and supported her through thick and thin. Related: Encanto Voice Cast Guide: What Every Character Looks Like In Real Life. Why is Abuela so disappointed in Mirabel when she also doesn't have a gift? But it seems clear fromEncanto's ending, in which powerless Mirabel saves the miracle, that everyone has an important role to play. All rights reserved. You can respect your abuela and tell her that you disagree with her ideas and how she sees things. Take into account what she witnessed in the span of a couple of days. Alma Madrigal | Encanto Wiki | Fandom Abuela's magic lies in how she creates an environment for the other Madrigals to flourish and use their gifts for good. Abuela was never really seen as a legitimate threat to the protagonists, but more of an obstacle to overcome in their journey to save the Encanto from El Rey. It's changed because Mirabel stood up for herself and for her family. We see evidence of this in Abuelas interactions with Mirabel throughout the film, as she is often dismissive of Mirabels abilities and seems to favor Mirabels more accomplished siblings. Being the only one without a gift made Mirabel feel left out of the family and led her to discover many family secrets, especially those about her mysterious uncle Bruno (John Leguizamo). She agreed with him being a perfect match, why was she so upset before? However, through the events of the film, she comes to realize the significance of letting go of the past and trusting the next generation to carry on the Madrigal legacy. On the surface, Abuela seems like a pretty straightforward character. That's why i strongly disagree with the Abuela is the problem theory. ""And then Tio tried to hide his rat but Tia didn't believe him so she tackled him," Mirabel explained happily to her amused Abuela." Mirabel bit her lip. Her change of heart in the movie shows that she realized her mistakes and made amends with her family. Meanwhile, Mirabel didn't get a power (a fact the village kids won't let her forget). why abuela is always mean to mirabel - TikTok That's why i strongly disagree with the Abuela is the problem theory. In the first few moments of the new Disney movie Encanto, we learn that a candle contains a miracle for the main characters, the family Madrigal. during isa and mira's fight, isa says "i have been stuck being perfect, my whole entire life, and literally, the only thing you have ever done for me is mess it up." As the film reaches its crescendo, we learn all this Madrigal pain is what's causing the magic to fade. However, when Mirabel, the only Madrigal member without a special gift, discovers that the magic that holds their family together is weakening, she seeks to find a way to save it. 8 clues in 'Encanto' that prove Mirabel is supposed to be the next Abuela Madrigals Read Mama Bear - Chapter 24 - Archive of Our Own Reddit, Inc. 2023. Why does Isabela did not stood up against Alma in the scene after her song? whereas their relationship in the early parts of the film have isabela annoyed and rolling her eyes at all of mirabel's attempts to help the family. THIS Is Why Abuela Was So Obsessed With Isabela! - YouTube In this context, it is easy to understand why Abuela may be resentful towards Mirabel. It actually makes sense, given what happens. As Isabela grew up, she grew to embody the spirit of Abuelas ancestors and embodied the values that she was raised to hold dear. Pepa, Felix, Julieta, Augustin, Isabela, Dolores and Luisa are adults, they aren't kids anymore. notes;--- 1. Among those is one that suggests that its all due to Abuela and her past actions and mistakes. Discover abuela being mean to mirabel stich 's popular videos - TikTok Encanto fan suggests harsh reason Mirabel doesn't have a gift The only member of her family who doesn't have magical powers, Mirabel is out to discover why the Madrigal clan's ancestral home is beginning to crumble, a mystery that her Abuela would. As such, Abuelas negative behavior towards Mirabel should be viewed through the lens of generational differences, cultural clashes, and personal struggles. Abuela constantly denies and dismisses Mirabels memories and experiences, making her feel like she is going crazy. First, Abuela neglected to keep her promise to the village elders not to reveal its secrets to the outside world. As the family works to heal and move forward, it is likely that Abuela will continue to grapple with these conflicting emotions and the role that Mirabel played in the familys troubles. Moreover, she ignored Mirabels feelings and failed to acknowledge her strengths and abilities, leading to Mirabel feeling that she was not enough. In some stories, Abuela is a beloved family figure who acts as a mother or grandmother figure while in others Abuela is a leader or matriarch. Mirabel's Secret Gift Explains Why Abuela Doesn't Actually Like Her.| Disney's EncantoIn Disney's Encanto, Abuela was shown to be a tough-loving grandmothe. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. we know that isabela is afraid of alma and what would happen, should she be perceived as anything less than perfect - as seen at the end of "what else can i do" - but by this point, all the resentment towards mirabel seemed to have gone away. Its not entirely clear whether Abuela is the sole reason that Mirabel didnt receive a gift, as there were likely many factors that contributed to the situation. Why Did Abuela Have To Be So Mean - TikTok This displacement left a lasting mark on Abuela, and she had difficulty emotionally resettling in a new country. If the theories that Mirabel and Abuela have the same hidden gift are to be believed, this may be why Abuela doesn't really like Mirabel at the beginning of Encanto. In the beginning, Abuela acts like Mirabel is useless for not having a power, and that the best thing she can do is stand to the side while the others work. Encanto: The Real Colombian Location Behind One Of Its Most Crucial Scenes. The problem is all the family. All of these examples allude to Mirabel's ability to one day take on Abuela's gift, her matriarchal mantle. 1 day ago, by Noelle Devoe Abuela's past trauma made her harsh on her family, especially so on Mirabel. While this is a bit harder to grasp than the more straightforward abilities like Camilo's shapeshifting, itactually showcases how Abuela is one of the most important family members because she keeps everybody together. thank you for reading! Abuela seemingly expresses that she can relate to Mirabel during the preparation for little Antonio's ceremony to reveal his power, saying the best way for "some of us" to help prepare is to stay . Encanto: Could Mirabel Become The Next Official Disney Princess? @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-mobile-leaderboard-1-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'remodelormove_com-mobile-leaderboard-1','ezslot_21',167,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-mobile-leaderboard-1-0');Abuela was so obsessed with Isabela because she was her only grandchild, the only direct connection to the familys past. However, there may be more to Abuela than some viewers realize. As Abuela addressesher past, she finally softens towards Mirabel. Even if she isn't directly responsible for Mirabel's lack of powers as the theory suggests, the fact is that Abuela Madrigal's backstory and the unexplained magic of Casita were the most interesting parts of Encanto.